Amish Pumpkin Butter Recipe | The Frugal Farm Wife (2024)

Canning/Preserving | Eat Well

ByElise New


Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

This Amish Pumpkin Butter recipe is easy enough to make large batches and can, delicious enough to eat on gluten-free bread sandwiches all fall and winter, and unique enough to hand out as hostess gifts at fall parties!

Amish Pumpkin Butter Recipe | The Frugal Farm Wife (1)

My husband is a sweet potato and winter squash lover in the extreme, and every year, he loves to plant a variety of new-to-him potatoes and squashes.

This year, one of his new squashes was a small pie pumpkin variety called New England Pie, and we just started harvesting them about two weeks ago.

For the record, I am NOT a sweet potato and winter squash lover. As I’m mostly Irish, I feel like my love for white potatoes is perfectly justified, and as I’m very, very white, despite also having Cherokee heritage, I’m not embarrassed at that I only love pumpkin if it’s heavily accompanied by pumpkin spice and well, not necessarily a latte, but definitely other ingredients that mask the texture of the pumpkin. #basicwhitegirltastebuds

With that in mind, I’m loving this variety of pumpkins.

    1. They’re on the small side, which make them easy for me to cut in half, deseed, and roast 1-2 per baking pan in the ever. Easy handling. Essential to the small homestead homemaker.
  1. They actually do taste really good. Like I said, I’m not a wintersquash/pumpkin lover, but I did taste these (for research purposes), and was surprised by how sweet they were.

So if you’re putting pumpkin in your garden next year 10/10 would recommend New England Pie pumpkins.

Amish Pumpkin Butter Recipe | The Frugal Farm Wife (2)

But that said, of course you can make this Amish Pumpkin Butter Recipe with any variety of pumpkin you wish – even canned pumpkin, which will definitely shorten the process up.

But if you’re a purist like me (only because we grew so many though tbh), grab a couple a small pie pumpkins, split them in half, deseed, and roast, cut side down, at 350º for, I dunno, an hour?

I have a tendency of not being very precise about chores like that – I put them in to roast while I’m doing school work with the kids at the kitchen table, and take them out when they’re soft enough to stick a fork through.

While I may not be a huge fan of pumpkin itself, you can bet I LOVE my pumpkin spice desserts. Like I said, white girl, even if I do stop short of Starbucks lattes (I just can’t get hyped about $5 coffee).

And this Amish pumpkin butter recipe?

This is the epitome of pumpkin spice.

So warm and spicy – much more spicy than pumpkin crunch cake, or sugar-free pumpkin cheese cake – and that makes it perfect to spread on toast or biscuits in the morning, because it’s deep spiciness carried through the butter, into every corner of your mouth.

Amish Pumpkin Butter Recipe | The Frugal Farm Wife (3)

Who knew that this perfect fall replacement for our usual jams and jellies would be as easy as stirring a few ingredients together, and ladling it into jars.

If you’ve made Crockpot pear butter, you’ll see that this recipe is very similar. Both are warm and spicy, but where pear butter is slightly tart and fruity, the pumpkin butter is smoother, warmer, and of course, have the distinct flavor of pumpkin to boot.


Amish Pumpkin Butter Recipe (With Canning Instructions)

Amish Pumpkin Butter Recipe | The Frugal Farm Wife (4)

Print Recipe
★★★★★ 4.7 from 10 reviews
  • Yield: 4 cups 1x



  • 4 cups of pumpkin purée (or two 15oz cans)
  • 1 1/4 cups sugar
  • 2 Tablespoons lemon juice
  • 2 Tablespoons pumpkin pie spice mix


  1. Stir ingredients together in a 4 quart of larger pan
  2. Heat over low or medium-low heat
  3. Continue cooking until pumpkin butter is thick and deep brown.
  4. Ladle into clean jars and seal

How to can:

  1. Use litmus paper to ensure your pumpkin butter is at a ph of 5.4 or lower before canning
  2. Transfer pumpkin butter to pint or half pint jars (I really like these jars)
  3. Wipe rims to insure there is no debris between rim and lid
  4. Top with flat and ring, and twist lids on fairly tightly
  5. Place into a pressure canner with a canning bottom so that jars are not in direct contact with heat source
  6. Fill pot with you canner’s recommended amount of water (mine is 2 quarts).Make sure that the water is as close to the same temperature as the pear butter as possible – if the butter is hot, use hot water, if the butter is cold, use cold water – to avoid jars breaking
  7. Secure lid, and heat over medium-high heat until steam begins to escape from steam valve
  8. Set your timer for ten minutes and continue to let canner steam
  9. Place pressure weights on the ten pound setting over steam valve
  10. Bring to pressure for 30 minutes
  11. Remove from hear and allow to cool inside canner for an hour or more if possible to avoid jars breaking when they come into contact with cool air
  12. Leave rings on sealed jars at least 24 hours before removing to clean and dry jars for storage
  13. Store in a cool dark place.
  14. Enjoy!

Get Your Garden Cheat Sheets!

Amish Pumpkin Butter Recipe | The Frugal Farm Wife (5)

Want to know exactly when, where, and how to plant your vegetables? Sign up to get our FREE companion planting guide, and garden planting cheat sheet printable.


Amish Pumpkin Butter Recipe | The Frugal Farm Wife (2024)


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terence Hammes MD

Last Updated:

Views: 6082

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terence Hammes MD

Birthday: 1992-04-11

Address: Suite 408 9446 Mercy Mews, West Roxie, CT 04904

Phone: +50312511349175

Job: Product Consulting Liaison

Hobby: Jogging, Motor sports, Nordic skating, Jigsaw puzzles, Bird watching, Nordic skating, Sculpting

Introduction: My name is Terence Hammes MD, I am a inexpensive, energetic, jolly, faithful, cheerful, proud, rich person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.